- Startup Strategist by stratup.ai
- Posts
- Against the Giants: Why Your Startup's Best Marketing Strategy is Having a Clear Villain
Against the Giants: Why Your Startup's Best Marketing Strategy is Having a Clear Villain
The strategic power of choosing your enemy before choosing your market

WELCOME TO

Estimated Read Time: 3- 4 minutes
Today’s Docket
News Stories:
AI Data Analyst Startup Julius Raises $10M Seed Round (TechCrunch)
CVector, Industrial AI Startup, Promises It Won’t Be Acquired (TechCrunch)
Startup Insight:
Against the Giants: Why Your Startup's Best Marketing Strategy is Having a Clear Villain
Startup Idea:
Social Spotlight:
New Claude Update
Resources:
Sticky Branding: "Every Hero Needs a Villain. What Is Your Brand Fighting For?"
Wild Fig Marketing: "Every Good Story Has a Villain: Using a Philosophical Problem To Sell Your Brand"
Today’s Sponsor
“Big Plastic” Hates Them
From water bottles to shrink wrap, Timeplast has a $1.3T market opportunity with its patented plastic that dissolves in water. But the clock is ticking to invest. You have until midnight, July 31 to become a Timeplast shareholder as they expand globally.
This is a paid advertisement for Timeplast’s Regulation CF Offering. Please read the offering circular at invest.timeplast.com.
Latest News from the World of Business
(1) AI Data Analyst Startup Julius Raises $10M Seed Round (TechCrunch)
Julius AI, an AI-first data analyst platform, closed a $10 million seed funding round led by Bessemer Venture Partners. Other backers include Horizon VC, 8VC, and YC, with high-profile angel investors such as Perplexity CEO Aravind Srinivas, Vercel CEO Guillermo Rauch, and Twilio co-founder Jeff Lawson joining the round. Julius, founded by Rahul Sonwalkar after his Y Combinator stint in 2022, aims to be an analyst that responds to natural-language prompts. The platform already counts over 2 million users and generates over 10 million visualizations.
(2) CVector, Industrial AI Startup, Promises It Won’t Be Acquired (TechCrunch)
Industrial AI startup CVector, serving utilities and manufacturers, is explicitly positioning itself as a long-term independent player—pledging it will not sell out to a tech giant. Concerned that clients fear acquisition instability, CVector founders share the assurance is critical to customer trust. The startup raised a $1.5 million pre‑seed round led by Schematic Ventures and is focused on mission-critical industrial operations.
Every superhero movie follows the same playbook. The hero isn't compelling for their powers, but for who they're fighting. Batman without the Joker is just a rich guy with gadgets. Superman without Lex Luthor is just an alien with a day job.
Your startup needs the same narrative tension.
While most founders obsess over crafting the perfect vision statement, the smartest ones are busy identifying their villain. They understand that humans don't rally around abstract visions—they rally against concrete threats. "Sometimes the best way to motivate people is to create the idea of an evil force" isn't just good storytelling advice; it's essential business strategy.
“People don’t buy what you do; they buy why you do it.”
Why Fighting "For" Something Isn't Enough
Speed, price, performance—classic positioning. It assumes customers are calculators. They’re not. They’re humans, wired for emotion and identity who buy what feels true, not just what looks efficient.
When you position your startup against something, you're not just selling a product. You're selling membership in a movement. You're offering customers a chance to be part of the resistance.
Consider these successful "villain-first" positioning strategies:
Bumble vs. Dating App Misogyny
Bumble's positioning strategy, which emphasizes female empowerment and lets women make the first move, sets it apart from other dating apps. This positioning helped the business achieve a market cap of $1.77 billion in 2024.
Stripe vs. Banking Bureaucracy
Stripe positioned itself against the nightmare of traditional payment processing. Their enemy wasn't PayPal but the soul-crushing experience of dealing with banks.
The Tribal Psychology of Opposition
Humans are wired for tribal thinking. We define ourselves as much by what we're against as what we're for. When your startup takes a clear stance against something, you activate this primal psychology.
Your customers stop being mere users. They become allies in your fight. They evangelize your cause. The opposition you choose becomes the glue that binds your community together.
This creates several powerful advantages:
Emotional differentiation: While competitors argue about features, you're fighting for principles
Built-in content strategy: Every move your "villain" makes becomes fodder for your messaging
Customer retention: People who join movements stay longer than people who just buy products
Word-of-mouth amplification: It's easier to share a cause than a product description
Choosing Your Villain: A Strategic Framework
1. They're Big Enough to Matter
Your villain needs to be significant enough that defeating them feels meaningful. Fighting a small competitor looks petty. Fighting an industry giant looks heroic.
2. They Have Clear Weaknesses
The most effective villains are those with obvious flaws your audience already resents. Big Tech's privacy violations. Traditional banks' fees. Enterprise software's complexity.
3. They Represent a Philosophical Difference
The best startup villains aren't just companies—they're worldviews. You're not just competing with their products; you're advocating for a fundamentally different way of doing things.
Common Startup Villains and How to Fight Them
Big Tech (Google, Facebook, Amazon)
Angle: Privacy, human connection, fair competition
Message: "Technology should serve people, not exploit them"
Examples: DuckDuckGo, Signal, Shopify
Traditional Industries (Banks, Insurance, Healthcare)
Angle: Accessibility, transparency, user experience
Message: "Essential services shouldn't require a PhD to understand"|
Examples: Square, Lemonade, Oscar Health
Enterprise Software Giants (Oracle, SAP, Salesforce)
Angle: Simplicity, affordability, modern design
Message: "Business software should empower, not frustrate"
Examples: Notion, Airtable, HubSpot
Status Quo Thinking
Angle: Innovation, disruption, progress
Message: "There's a better way to do everything"
Examples: Airbnb vs. hotels, Uber vs. taxis
Avoiding the Villain Trap
Villain-based positioning comes with risks. Done wrong, it can backfire spectacularly:
Don't Attack Individuals
Target systems, not people. "Banking is broken" works. "Jamie Dimon is evil" doesn't.
Stay Focused on Solutions
Criticism without alternatives just makes you a complainer. Always pair your attacks with your vision for something better.
Don't Become the Thing You Fight
Success can corrupt your mission. Facebook started as an alternative to MySpace's chaos but became the very privacy villain others now fight.
Building Your Anti-Hero Narrative
Once you've identified your villain, every piece of content becomes an opportunity to reinforce the narrative:
Origin story: How you discovered the problem your villain represents
Battle updates: Regular content showing how you're advancing the fight
Victory celebrations: Highlighting wins against the status quo
Ally spotlights: Featuring customers who've joined your cause
Your marketing stops being about you and starts being about the movement you're leading.
Stop trying to be everything to everyone. Start being something powerful to someone. Build your villain, then rally your tribe to fight it.
You Might Want to Read:
Sticky Branding: "Every Hero Needs a Villain. What Is Your Brand Fighting For?"
Wild Fig Marketing: "Every Good Story Has a Villain: Using a Philosophical Problem To Sell Your Brand"
Startup Idea: Affordable Sports Equipment Marketplace
Finding reliable and affordable sports equipment and gear can be a challenge for many enthusiasts. The options are often limited, and the prices are high, especially when looking for quality products. A startup that focuses on providing a wide range of sports equipment at competitive prices while maintaining quality standards could fill this gap in the market. By establishing partnerships with manufacturers and leveraging economies of scale, this startup could offer a variety of sports gear, from running shoes to tennis rackets, at prices that are more accessible to a broader audience.
Worth Your Attention:
Claude can now read and update your @NotionHQ pages and @linear tickets directly through MCP.
Connect your workspace tools and let Claude help manage your projects, update documentation, and track issues—all from one conversation.
— Anthropic (@AnthropicAI)
7:01 PM • Jul 28, 2025
Sponsored Content
Create How-to Videos in Seconds with AI
Stop wasting time on repetitive explanations. Guidde’s AI creates stunning video guides in seconds—11x faster.
Turn boring docs into visual masterpieces
Save hours with AI-powered automation
Share or embed your guide anywhere
How it works: Click capture on the browser extension, and Guidde auto-generates step-by-step video guides with visuals, voiceover, and a call to action.
Was this Newsletter Helpful? |
Put Your Brand in Front of 15,000+ Entrepreneurs, Operators & Investors.
Sponsor our newsletter and reach decision-makers who matter. Contact us at [email protected]
Image by Liuzishan on freepik.
Disclaimer: The startup ideas shared in this forum are non-rigorously curated and offered for general consideration and discussion only. Individuals utilizing these concepts are encouraged to exercise independent judgment and undertake due diligence per legal and regulatory requirements. It is recommended to consult with legal, financial, and other relevant professionals before proceeding with any business ventures or decisions.
Sponsored content in this newsletter contains investment opportunity brought to you by our partner ad network. Even though our due-diligence revealed no concerns to us to promote it, we are in no way recommending the investment opportunity to anyone. We are not responsible for any financial losses or damages that may result from the use of the information provided in this newsletter. Readers are solely responsible for their own investment decisions and any consequences that may arise from those decisions. To the fullest extent permitted by law, we shall not be liable for any direct, indirect, incidental, special, or consequential damages, including but not limited to lost profits, lost data, or other intangible losses, arising out of or in connection with the use of the information provided in this newsletter.